Saturday, March 5, 2011

Weather the Weather

*Licks finger & holds it up in the air* Yep, the wind is definitely blowing from... who the hell knows where. Weathermen certainly don't. They can't be trusted.

Just as I was about to begin writing this post about my fascination/obsession with weather phenomena, I saw on Twitter that Nola.com had just posted an article stating that there is a tornado watch in the New Orleans area. So instead of continuing to track my thoughts on what I was going to write, I went to a weather site to see if there were any tornado watches in my area and just to check the weather generally. You might think, "Oh, that's pretty normal. I mean, if there's a tornado watch or warning in your area, you'd probably want to know about it, right?" Yes. Except that I don't live in New Orleans. I'm 6 hours away from that watch area...

In case of inclement weather in my area actually, though, I've been known to spend hours switching between Wunderground, NOAA, Weather.com, and IntelliCast comparing maps, graphs, and forecasts, and reading updates to the Scientific Forecaster Discussion.

So now you have the tiniest inkling into my hyperactive sensitivity to weather. We could spend all day speculating about why that is... maybe when I was little I dropped a would-be-delicious cup of milk on the floor because the thunder from a sudden storm scared me. That's a really specific hypothetical, so maybe I should explore that with a therapist one day, but the truth is, it's not as important to know why I'm so intrigued by the weather. I just am. What I really want to know is how do weathermen get paid so well to NOT predict the weather accurately?!

The "no hype" weathermen in my area are exactly the opposite of what they assume to be. If the Super Mega High Resolution Dopplar 6000 Radar shows twirling clouds and heavy thunderstorms dropping potentially deadly hail in the area just west of me and indicates that this supercell is heading toward my house, then their highly-trained, super smooth voices are not going to reassure me that all is well. I can see the vortexes, Bob. They're on that screen behind you. I think I even just saw you cry a little. So that's when I start asking myself, "What do they know that they're not telling me?" That's when I turn to the above sites. But is it because they're more accurate? No! Absolutely not! So then why check, you ask?

Well here it is:  Knowledge is power. What they don't tell me, I feel like I have to figure out on my own.

Once I'm on those sites, though, I really have to scrutinize the information with which they provide me. If the above 4 sites all give a different "probability" for rain on a given day, then I am compelled to examine why. And while I am no mathematician, I do realize that 70% does not equal 100%. But how many times have I banked on having a "snow day" that will force schools to shut down and all outdoor human activity to come to a grinding halt (this is the south after all), only to find that not only will there be no snow, there isn't even enough moisture in the few clouds there are in the sky to give us a light rain; that it's a beautiful, sunny day with a high of 35º F and not a chance of any precipitation whatsoever?! OR alternate scenario: when all of the above sites say there is a 60% chance of thunderstorms during this hour & throughout the next 5... but it's been raining like buckets pouring from the heavens for a half hour? That's not a 60% chance of rain... that's a 100% chance. Because it's raining. Right now. With no sign of stopping, ever.

In my very humble opinion, the "science" of meteorology is dubious at best. Data compiled from years of historical weather records are all well and good, but today is a new day. The truth is that weather is as unpredictable as what I'm going to do next. Because I don't even know... I'm just spontaneous like that.

8 comments:

  1. Hahaha! I love it! I really do wish I had a job that paid me well to be wrong 80% of the time! Why even 'predict' if you know you're gonna be wrong! At best you can predict that you'll be wrong every day! I mean... that should be a profession! Predicting the accuracy of a weather report?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Agreed! I'd apply for that job in a heartbeat!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I feel sorry for that weatherman. His job is to"do his best" while everyone is watching. I know what you mean though, planning for rain then not having any is irksome. I wonder if living in a climate that varies a lot would quell your weather fixation ... or make it worse?

    ReplyDelete
  4. First of all, bless you for leaving a comment. :) I see your point, but I just can't bring myself to feel sorry for him. He gets paid 6 figures to prepare the public for the weather, which is crazy because there isn't enough data in the world to accurately predict what's going to happen. So I guess it's not his fault... it's the fault of the guy paying that 6 figure salary, lol. And to answer your question, I think it would only get worse... my neurotic fascination with the weather runs deep... ;)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have a theory. I think there are a lot of jobs like meteorology, they just get paid less. Take our job, for example. We could teach our students that people in France wear their underwear outside of their pants, they say "Tu es stupide" as a common greeting, and that French was originally spoken by Native Americans who traveled to Europe and taught it to the people living there. We would have maybe 5 students question us, and 1 of those 5 would probably find out we were "inaccurate". So we could be like meteorologists and be wrong 80% of the time. The difference is we get paid WAY less and we have integrity. Not to say our local weatherman doesn't have integrity or anything... :)
    Katie

    ReplyDelete
  6. Haha... good one, Katie. :) I don't even know where to begin to respond to that. Just... yes.

    ReplyDelete
  7. "Tu es Stupide"-(lol) I am greeting all of our 6th grade French students with this today, and they are saying "Bon jour Monsieur Stock".

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hahahaha Blair!! Thanks for coming to read my humble blog & for leaving that HYSTERICAL comment! love it! :D Kudos to Katie for the awesome idea ;)

    ReplyDelete

Popular Posts